Elkhart County, Indiana

One table.
One evening.
Entirely yours.

A private dinner for two, produced from first candle to last course — so the only thing you have to do is show up and be somewhere unforgettable together.

See the Evenings Check a Date
01

Choose an evening

Three of them, already planned down to the last candle. Pick the feeling you want.

See the three → 02

Find a date

See which nights are still open and hold one before someone else does.

Open the calendar → 03

Meet who's cooking

One family in northern Indiana. Mom, two sisters, and a sister-in-law.

About us →

The Evenings

Three evenings, already imagined

You don't have to plan a thing. Choose the feeling you want — we've built the rest, down to the last detail.

The Candlelit

Intimate & warm

$850for two

  • A multi-course dinner, cooked for the two of you alone
  • A table set in candlelight, styled start to finish
  • Wine chosen to match each course
  • A hand-lettered sign made just for your evening
  • Someone attending your table all night — you never lift a finger
Choose This Evening
Most Chosen

The Garden

Open air & golden hour

$1,000for two

  • Everything in The Candlelit
  • Dinner outdoors as the light goes gold
  • Fresh flowers arranged for your table that day
  • A photographer for the evening's first hour
  • A framed photograph of the two of you — printed before you leave
Choose This Evening

The Occasion

For the night that matters most

$1,400for two

  • Everything in The Garden
  • A live musician playing through dinner
  • An extended menu, written around your story
  • A keepsake menu with both your names on it
  • Quiet help with the moment — if you're planning one
Choose This Evening

Dinners for four to six, and fully bespoke evenings, begin at $1,800. Just ask — we'll build it with you.

Why We Do This

The Ritz can give you a beautiful room

What it cannot do is know that he proposed to her in the rain, or that her grandmother made this exact pie every Christmas.

We're one family in northern Indiana who have spent our whole lives feeding people — and we noticed something. Around here you can find a good meal. What you cannot find is an evening: a night designed entirely around two people, where every candle and every course was chosen because of who is sitting there.

So we made it. You tell us a little about the two of you. We take care of the other hundred decisions, and you walk into something that feels like it could only ever have been yours.

About Us

Four women, eighty years of feeding people

Not a staff — a family. Mom, two sisters, and a sister-in-law. When you book an evening, these are the hands it passes through, and no one else's.

Nicole

Nicole

Sister

Twenty years in restaurants and the owner of her own coffee shop. She runs the room, and she'll be the one who greets you at the door and remembers what you told her weeks ago.

Josh’s mom

Mom

The one it all comes from

Two decades of cooking for everyone who ever walked through her door. If a dish on your menu tastes like someone's been making it their whole life, it's because she has.

Sarah

Sarah

Sister

Cooks alongside her mother and sister, and has the eye that decides how a plate — and a whole table — should look before anyone sits down.

Hannah

Hannah

Sister-in-law

Event planning at Notre Dame, and the hand behind every sign we letter for you. She's the reason the evening looks the way it does.

How It Works

Four steps, and three of them are ours

Tell us the date

Send us the evening you have in mind. We'll confirm within a day whether we can hold it.

One short conversation

Fifteen minutes. What you're celebrating, what she loves, anything we should avoid.

We build the evening

Menu, table, flowers, music, the sign with your names. You hear nothing until it's ready.

You just arrive

Walk in at seven. Everything is done. Leave with photographs and a very good night.

May – October

Outdoors

Garden dinners under open sky, timed so you're seated as the light turns.

November – April

The Coffee Shop

Nicole's shop, closed to everyone but you. Small, warm, and entirely private.

Year round

Your Place

Have somewhere in mind? We've hosted in family homes before. Ask us.

Check a Date

Let's see if we're free

Tell us roughly what you're thinking. We answer every message ourselves, usually the same day.

SMTWTFS

Evenings still open

That didn't send — something went wrong on our end, not yours. Please email us directly at dining@mullet.town and we'll take it from there.

No payment now, and nothing is booked until we've talked.
We'll reply within one day.

Thank you — it's on its way.

We'll be in touch within a day to talk through your evening.